遭質疑用Auto-Tune、預錄？韓V「常乃メリ」完美歌唱表現掀網上熱議

日前出道的韓國 VTuber 事務所 StelLive 四期生「常乃メリ」，因初配信展現出近乎完美的歌唱表現，遭部分網友質疑是否使用 Auto-Tune（自動調諧），或是否真的為現場演唱，相關討論在網路上持續發酵。

有網友表示，自己更希望聽到「未經後製修飾的真實聲音」認為若使用自動調諧而不公開說明是一種欺騙；也有人公開音高線條圖，指出其中存在明顯的修音痕跡，並質疑如此穩定且高水準的演出，在一般直播環境下難以達成，因此對是否為現場演唱抱持懷疑態度。

🚨 Hot take but I lowkey feel like using auto tune without disclosure during a live karaoke is deceiving and dishonest.

While I myself have a vocal chain setup within obs for standard processing (eq, comp, noise removal etc.) I've never once used auto-tune for live vocals. It feels just straight up dishonest.

As a stage actress/opera singer, auto tune just isn't an option for classical in-person performances. It forces you to truly work on your vocal technique and improve as a singer.

No hate to anyone who chooses to pass their pitch corrected vocals off as naturals but it's for sure not for me.

— Astrea Colornatura 🌿🐏【lucid ☁️】 (@AstreaNatura)October 21, 2026

Not to rain on anyone's parade buuuuuuuut.... this is a *heavily* produced vocal, including autotune, mixing, and mastering.

If it's live at all, she's basically singing into a whole DAW project mixing the song in real time with transitions, effects... or it might not be live. https://t.co/H6ZG6Tcx1n

— Hoshino Lina / 星乃リナ 🩵 3D Yuri Wedding prep!!! (@Lina_Hoshino)October 19, 2026

不過，多數網友持相反意見。有音訊工程師指出，以現今技術搭建低延遲、具備即時效果處理的直播環境已不罕見，但能維持如此穩定的水準，代表歌手本身具備相當高的實力。也有人認為，偏好未經處理的原始音色屬於個人喜好，不應以此作為批評他人的依據。

Mini ramble 🧵:
I think Tokino Mery's debut is a great example of how a good singer's stream is enhanced by a great audio setup. There's been some discourse going around how some people think the performance was pre-recorded, or heavily produced, which confuses me.

Auto-tune… https://t.co/1qyikuMfAL

— OSCEN || AUDIO + SOUND DESIGN (@heyitsoscen)October 20, 2026

めちゃくちゃ整った環境で歌ってることだけは分かったけどリアルタイムの配信でこれをやる為のエフェクター類が気になりすぎるDAWでやってるとして何を噛ませているの…！ 上質な音響すぎてすごい てか何よりクソクソクソ歌がうまくてこの技術が欲しすぎる なんでこの歌いまわしで余裕があるんだ？www

— 七 ┊ nano 🩶7️⃣️🩵 11/7新衣装 (@7_nanochan)October 20, 2026

在初配信結束後，常乃メリ近期在 CHZZK 開啟遊戲直播，為通關《Get To Work》連續遊玩長達 9 小時；過程中她亦演唱了〈明日的夜空哨戒班〉，再次以唱功帶給觀眾驚喜。

토키노 메리🪡🧸｜2026.10.21

🎼Orangestar
🎵내일의 밤하늘 초계반「アスノヨゾラ哨戒班」

#maryclip_ https://t.co/GIxgaVuOpR

— 밀키스 주머니 (@Pop_Muses)October 21, 2026